I do not know if anybody but Mormons even know what trunk-or-treating is. It is not a doctrinal thing, just cultural. So no, the Book of Mormon does not say anything like, “Other treats I have who are not of this bowl.” It’s not like that.
What is trunk-or-treating? Simply put, it is trick-or-treating in a parking lot—but instead of moving house to house, you move from parking stall to parking stall. Not all Mormons trunk-or-treat, but most Mormons who belong to a congregation of any size in the United States would have at least had the opportunity to attend a trunk-or-treat.
My best guess is that the trunk-or-treat came about because some Mormon did not want his or her child(ren) to go trick-or-treating some year that Halloween fell on a Sunday but felt guilty when it came down to depriving his or her child(ren) of the experience.
Trunk-or-treating in many congregations now occurs every year, irrespective of whether or not Halloween falls on a Sunday. Some congregations insist on having trunk-or-treating on Halloween provided that it does not fall on Sunday. Simply put, this really misses the point. Kids do not like trunk-or-treating more than trick-or-treating. They just like trunk-or-treating more than staying home and playing Uno or whatever else they would have done.
If you get a chance to go trunk-or-treating, what should you expect? As you approach the trunk-or-treat in the church parking lot, you will see a bunch of kids dressed in pretty regular Halloween costumes—with perhaps a tad more Brooke White costumes than you might see outside of American mainstream.
The spectacle of the event is the decked out minivans and SUVs. Not all people go to the effort. Yet, a fair number do. You may ask, are not all the Goldfish and Nilla Wafers smashed into the minivan’s carpet scary enough? You would think that the tab for gassing up that Range Rover would pretty much make those crepe paper bats pretty much an afterthought. But, no. Some will decorate their cars, some adults will dress up. There is no need for dry ice; the emissions from all the running vehicles pretty much will take care of anyone that feels it necessary to have fake fog. It doesn’t really matter much whether people dress up, whether they decorate, or whether the kids themselves will be asphyxiated walking from car to car so long as people have candy. And, Mormons do have candy and generally Costco size bags of it to boot.
Before the trunk-or-treat, expect Mormons to have refreshments. This will most likely consist of doughnuts and maybe hot chocolate or hot apple cider. You might be thinking, “Doughnuts and hot chocolate before gorging on candy? Really?” The explanation for this is pretty simple: Mormons are always looking for loopholes in the Word of Wisdom. Any holiday of respectable size pretty much gives Mormons a free pass to ignore that whole “moderation in all things” mantra.
Anyways, for all of those going trick-or-treating and/or trunk-or-treating, have a spooky one.
Man versus Ferrell
-
I love Discovery Network show Man versus Wild. I rarely get to watch it
though. However, am really glad that my wife turned on the DVR for this one.
21 comments:
Our trunk-or-treat this year will be a heathier one... we're starting with a chili cookoff. So now you can chug the Tums along with the Smarties.
Love it! I just finished making some cupcakes for the cake-walk during the "carnival" in the cultural hall beforehand. My kids are going to be so full of sugar by the end of the night! I love this blog - it's great!
True story. When I was a teenager (not that long ago) my ward had a new bishop who decided that there would be no Trunk-or-Treat (he was super-opposed to Halloween, I guess). Fast forward a few years, and the ward gets split in half in early October, and the other ward is the one that the Bishop lives in.
Trunk-or-Treat was back on in my ward immediately.
Love your Blog! Our ward did Trunk or Treat last night and I did bring Costco size bags of candy.
Brigham, this almost makes me want to be a Mormon.
What I want to know is, what kind of church celebrates Halloween?
Our Branch discontinued this tradition several years ago, and boy is it a relief! We also have no Santa Claus at our Christmas party. (No thread-jack intended.)
Hate trunk-or-treat, but then I'm not a huge halloween fan. But let it be noted, that a couple of years ago I spent more than $100 making a Halloween costume for my adult daughters.
************
What I want to know is, what kind of church celebrates Halloween? --- Can you give it a break? Maybe it USED to be a pagan holiday, but for decades it's just been an excuse to dress up and eat lots of chocolate. Seriously, who cares? I'm pretty sure we won't get sent to HELL for dressing up our kid like a clown/cowboy/princess one day a year.
Just thought I'd add that my daughter's elementary school (in NV) has a trunk-or-treat every year at their fall festival, so it does exist outside the LDS realm.
Four comments. First one to Maren. I get your frustration with Halloween. That been said, I think the vast majority of Mormons dig it, including trunk-or-treating. That does not make it good or bad, just fodder for What Mormons Like.
Second, Chantel, one great thing about Mormons is that they love people to come to their activities whether or not they are members. If you want to go trunk-or-treating next year somewhere in your neck of the woods, contact me, and I bet I can help arrange it.
Third, emily d., your comment is interesting, but I would have been more convinced if you had given me an example outside of the Interior West. My guess is that some Mormon or someone familiar with Mormon trunk-or-treating got this thing going in NV.
Last comment, ashley I love the fact that your ward is giving out cupcakes before candy.
To the rest of you, I enjoyed the comments. I would be intereted in hearing more from Mos out there who did go trunk-or-treating.
I have a friend in Alabama who went trunk or treating at the local community church. I think it's new in the South. When I lived there 18 yrs ago no one did trunk or treating including us Mormons.
i have no idea who came up with trunk-or-treating first, but IN GENERAL it always cracks me up when just because most/a lot of mormons do something that "we" claim it as a mormon thing....when often it's not, we just embrace it, maybe add our own spin on it, or if we live in a place where mormons exist in a high concentration, we automatically assume it's a mormon culture phenomenon ... when if we just stepped outside of our little mormon bubble, we'd see that we aren't that weird after all because lots of non-mormons do the same thing.
I'm kind of glad to see trick or treating on the way out. It's been on the dangerous side for many years now. Side note and kinda funny: Where my daughter lives, it is a law(?)that registered child predators had to have a sign on their door that said 'No Candy' so kids wouldn't knock on their doors. I chuckled at it and thought that this city would not allow that to happen. Thought it was interesting.
Amy, Just because other people do things that Mormons do, it does not mean that (a) these things do not qualify as things that Mormons like or (b) that Mormons aren't weird. Regardless, I am glad to have you as a reader.
I agree Brigham, sorry I didn't clarify my comment better. I really wasn't disagreeing with what you said, just making a general observation of my own with regards to "mormon" things. Things don't have to be purely mormon to be something mormons like and mormons are weird, so there's no argument there ;-)
I live in the South (Austin, TX) where trunk or treating endures in the Mormon culture. The wards end up arguing over who gets the church parking lot on what night. We usually end up with Halloween night, having it right around dinner time before it gets dark. The kids love it because it's basically a double whammy. First we trunk or treat, dump the goods at home, then head out for neighborhood treating. We Mormons know how to make the most of Halloween.
I'm Matt Asay's sister, btw. LOVE your blog!
I have to admit--I am Mormon, but I'm not necessarily the biggest fan of the trunk-or-treat thing...at least, not on Halloween nights. There's just fun memories about tripping over my long cape on my way to the neighbor's house to get candy, rather than just doing it all through a parking lot....You appreciate what you have to work for! I do admit that trick-or-treating is getting much more dangerous (dumb people, ruining things for everyone else), but I miss the old days. Then again, I don't have little kids (yet), so I'm sure that, given 5 years and 6 kids, I'll have a different perspective. :)
Living in an Iowa,small, mostly Lutheran town I have seen the most conservative Lutheran congregation doing trunk-or-treating year after year. They are very proud of this tradition and claim that they made it up.
blair said:
Here in Hattiesburg Mississippi trunk or treating is practiced by several churches, schools, businesses, etc. It's going mainstream I reckon.
Okay, trunk-or-treat might be just something that Mormons do rather than something Mormons made up. I can live with that.
However, if you know that Mormons did not create Hawaiian Haystacks, keep that to yourself. Let me live with that joy... even if it is lie.
Yeah but what about no bake cookies, the kind with oat meal, peanut butter, and chocolate. There can't be anyone but Mormon college students who call them gorilla poop. I'm sure it started in the Heritage Halls being prepared for FHE back in the late 80's. They've been a big hit with cub scouts ever since.
For the record, the Ada County Sherrif Department in Boise, ID sponsored a community Trunk or Treating event where deputies handed out candy from various departmental vehicles so it is getting out there.
Post a Comment