Monday, April 20, 2009

Mormons Like/Will Like Susan Boyle

If you have not already seen it, you should check out this clip from Britain's Got Talent. I know, however, there is a fair chance that you are among the 30 million others who have already watched Susan Boyle's performance.

Up to this point, this blog has cataloged those things that Mormons like. My approach has been pointing out the familiar and often the obvious.

I am going out on a limb here. In saying that Mormons like or will like Susan Boyle, I am telling you something nobody has pointed out yet. In doing so, there is a risk involved because I may be wrong about Susan Boyle's performance. However, the risk is not too grave because the probability that anyone would care that I was wrong is not very great and the probability that I would care if they did is even more slim.

So, here are a few reasons why I think that Mormons like or will like Susan Boyle's performance. There might be more, but this is a start.

  • Mormons love the stories about the imprudence of judging a book by its cover, but her story is better than that. She is the Old Violin, Mr. Kruger living alone with her cat, and the lonely woman waiting by the mailbox all rolled up in one.
  • She looks like somebody you might see at church, but she can really sing--a rare combination indeed. I have said before, Mormons have heard much more of their share of bad music. When someone who looks to have come straight from the Relief Society comes out and belts out a song like she does, it truly is a relief for Mormon society.
  • Susan Boyle's performance provides a great springboard for drawing gospel-related analogies. Her sharing her music, of course, is like church members sharing the Gospel. Her unflappable composure in the face of a jeering crowd is just as a reminder to look past the things of the world. Her reference to her cat Pebbles is like... like... er... really great, and I am sure full of symbolic meaning too.
  • In the Internet video of her performance (between 4 minutes even and 4 minutes and 5 seconds to be precise), Simon Cowell looks like a baby smiling due to gas. Mormons love it when babies smile even if it is just gas.
  • Her performance changed the mind of the audience, the judges, and presumably most of the people watching her video on the Internet. Mormons like it when optimism and gumption overcomes cynicism and timidity.
* Back to the obvious: Funeral potatoes out of the blue says, "I know you need potatoes, cream of mushroom soup, and cheese--even on days that people don't die." If you liked this brief thought, I suggest you subscribe to my tweets on Twitter.

15 comments:

Lucy said...

Don't you just hope/pray it wasn't a set up? You know the ratings games today. It's like too good to be true. Loved it though.

kaye said...

great link, great post--I think mormons will like Susan Boyle. But I still don't think they will like Pierce.

Anna said...

I saw that clip yesterday, but now I am tempted to go back and look for that smile. Not tempted enough to actually do it, though.

JAMIE said...

Don't forget to mention the Mormons love Les Miserables too, and she sang one of the most popular songs.

I think it was Ezra T Benson that touted the virture of Les Mis. Well except for the "lovely ladies" song...;)

Melonie said...

I don't think the limb is going to break - you've gone out on a good strong one. Susan Boyle is definitely going to be liked by Mormons. GOOD CALL!

Ranisa said...

Try using the cream of chicken instead of cream of mushroom.....

by the way GREAT post!

Bryan said...

To lend credence to your theory, there's already a story on Mormon Times (Deseret News' LDS section) about Boyle, who apparently "owes her dazzling voice to a teenage obsession with Donny Osmond," according to her brother (link).

Well, I think that pretty much sews it up: Susan, you're officially a Faux-Mo.

Brigham said...

Jamie and Bryan, Thanks for drawing our attention to these important points. It was sloppy that I did not pick up on the Les Miserables tie. Mormons really like musicals but Les Miserables is certainly top of the heap. Bryan, I did not know about the Mormon Times article. This is big news though. I think it is almost big enough to start spreading the rumor that she joined the church as a teenager. Let me be the first to say, she did in fact.

preparednesspro said...

Yep, Mormons do like Susan Boyle! Have you seen her new makeover? Good bye, bushy eyebrows...

http://preparednesspro.wordpress.com

Lori said...

okay so I read this a couple days ago, watched the video, looked for the smile, thought it was hilarious (simon) but also moving. you can't deny the fact that she's talented.

what makes me fall over in laughter though, was at the end of a pretty serious talk given by a church leader this weekend (not high up, but at the stake-ish level) he told us how he had wanted to show us a video but couldn't get the equipment to work.

Then he wrote "Susan Boyle" up on the board and asked us if we saw it, and proceeded to give an account and talk about what a great inspiration she is. As true a point as it was, I couldn't help but think "I need to go comment on that post now..."

It's official. Mormons like Susan Boyle.

Brigham said...

Lori:

I am thrilled to hear that a representative your stake understood that Mormons would like Susan Boyle. I am sure he had his audience hook-line-and-sinker.

But, do tell more. What specifically did he say? Did he use Boyle to teach a gospel principle? Did he use an analogy? Did he break out and start singing Les Miserables? Please tell me that his talk ended with, "Who am I? 24601!"

I would love to hear more.

Amanda said...

You could also add that it makes people cry and Mormon's like a tear jerker now and then--not as much as your rainbow show, but just a tear or two.

Lori said...

It was something along the lines of how people will doubt you and be against you but... that you can show them who's got talent? I know the first part is right, not so much the second.
Basically gospel principle of adversity.

Jewel said...

Actually, before I'd even seen the video of Susan Boyle, I heard about her--from my Sunday School teacher, who used her as a gospel analogy of overcoming cynicism. Loved it. :)

Lynn said...

I blogged about her recently and she is so adopted into the Mo fold now !